Episodes
Enjoy all of our episodes, complete with show notes and transcripts.
New episodes come out every other Tuesday.
Latest Episode
Ep. 122
Lip Balm
24 February 2026
A string of deaths leads a pair of detectives on a hunt all over town. Their only clue? All the victims used the same drugged lip balm.
Previous Episodes
Christmas Lights
When down-and-out Victoria goes for a late-night walk in the middle of her company Christmas party, a peculiar sight draws her into the strange world of Christmas Land. There she meets Santa’s daughter, a friendly polar bear, a magical talking doll, and together they help to save Christmas.
Balloons
Ten years ago in the small town of Echo Valley, a school bus full of children disappeared. Amy was supposed to be on that bus, but she faked an illness to stay home and her life was spared. One day, a couple dozen brightly colored balloons gently float down from the sky bringing with them mementos belonging to the missing children. Things get even stranger when Amy’s classmates return to the town—and they haven’t aged a day. The mystery reaches new heights when the truth about Amy’s life over the past decade is revealed, and she learns of the difficult decision she must make for her future.
Cranberry Sauce
An ancient curse has resurrected a monster in a local cranberry bog, and the characters from our Bread Maker episode must work together to deal with this new threat.
Pamphlet
When an autistic librarian is cajoled by her jealous co-worker into writing a self-help pamphlet about romantic relationships (a topic in which she has no actual experience) it leads to a “comedic” misunderstanding—and her first real romance.
Bones
This year it was Shep’s turn to choose the location for the Halloween episode, and he chose a diner because it’s indoors. While enjoying their meals, the trio share stories centered around bones. Luckily, being indoors this year means no harm should manage to befall them. And yet, there seem to be an awful lot of sirens outside…
Sweater
A cursed sweater that appeared in a classic slasher film claims new victims after being purchased by a fan.
Coaster
An aging artist flew too close to the sun with a famous series of decorated beverage coasters in her youth. Now, years later, she finds herself at a bar without the means to pay. It’s suggested that she decorate another coaster in lieu of payment. She reluctantly agrees, and the endeavor brings up difficult memories and feelings for the artist.
Pencil
John Cena and Michael Cera team up again, this time as a bush pilot and tech CEO who crash land in the jungle. They get captured by a sex cult, forced into manual labor by a death squad, and set a revolution in motion. Through it all they rely on each other—and their pencils.
Fireflies
Marty comes from a family that uses spirit animals in battle, but on the day he receives his powers, instead of a strong animal like a tiger or a bear, he receives fireflies. Although this power seems useless at first, he learns to harness his abilities and ends up playing a pivotal role in saving his village.
Hot Sauce
Jeremy Renner is a wizard’s apprentice from another dimension where magic can be found in hot sauces. After he is unexpectedly transported to our dimension, he must find a way to return home and save his magical mentor. Complicating his return is his dwindling supply of magical peppers… And an unexpected celebrity foe.
